Cliff Booth First Reactions: Brad Pitt's Sequel Is an 'Absolute Triumph'

The first verdicts are in — and Brad Pitt's return as Cliff Booth is a triumph. The social media embargo on The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth lifted on Monday night, and the first critics to see David Fincher's sequel to Once Upon a Time… in Hollywood are calling it one of the best films of the year. The film opens exclusively in IMAX on November 25 before arriving on Netflix on December 23.
What the First Reactions Say
The response from the first screenings has been close to unanimous. The Wrap's senior film reporter Drew Taylor called the film “an absolute triumph”, writing that “Tarantino and Fincher are like peanut butter and chocolate.” Variety's Clayton Davis described it as “a wild, hilarious hangout movie”, saying Pitt gives his best performance since the 2019 original and singling out Elizabeth Debicki for bringing “an intoxicating sensuality” — adding that “if the 2019 film was a love letter to L.A., this one is a full-on sonnet.”
The praise kept coming. Critic Germain Lussier called it his favourite movie of the year, “and it's not even close.” Simon Thompson wrote that the film “pops, throbs and crackles,” calling it “a salty and slower-burning side piece to Tarantino's original with a fire final act.” Critics Choice member Ricky Válero called it an “absolute banger” and “truly one of the year's best films,” while Zach Pope summed up the collaboration as “a PURE cinematic trifecta of Tarantino's signature chaos, Fincher's meticulous attention to detail, and Brad Pitt's effortlessly charismatic Cliff Booth.”
The Film: Fincher Directs, Tarantino Writes
The sequel is one of the most unusual pairings in modern Hollywood: Quentin Tarantino wrote the screenplay — his first draft reportedly ran 230 pages, with Fincher cutting around 60 — and David Fincher, the director of Se7en, Fight Club and The Social Network, took the chair. Pitt returns as Cliff Booth, the stuntman role that won him the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor in 2019. The story jumps to 1977, eight years after the first film, with Cliff now working as a fixer for Hollywood's elite, taking jobs that mix crime, ambition and desire. The cast includes Elizabeth Debicki as Karen Crosby, Scott Caan, Carla Gugino, Yahya Abdul-Mateen II and Peter Weller. Netflix lists the runtime at 2 hours and 23 minutes.
Why It Matters — and What Happens Next
The reactions matter because this is not a routine sequel. Pitt is reuniting with Fincher, the director who helped make him a star in Se7en and Fight Club, in the role that won him his Oscar — and the early word is that the combination works. With the film hitting IMAX screens on November 25, just before Thanksgiving, and landing on Netflix on December 23, the glowing first reactions have already put it in the awards conversation for 2027.
Pitt is having a big week beyond Cliff Booth, too. In an interview with Variety he confirmed that Ocean's 14 is aiming to start production late next year, with George Clooney, Julia Roberts, Matt Damon and Don Cheadle expected to return and David Leitch directing — and an Ocean's Eleven prequel starring Margot Robbie and Bradley Cooper is also on the way. Between a triumphant return as Cliff Booth and the Ocean's franchise coming back to life, Pitt's 2027 is already shaping up to be one of his biggest years yet.
A word of caution: first reactions are social media posts from early screenings, and they are enthusiastic by nature. The full critical picture will only emerge once more people have seen the film. But for now, the message from the first audience is clear — Cliff Booth is back, and Hollywood's most unlikely team-up has delivered.
Stay with SNAPNEWS for the full review and box office coverage when The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth opens in IMAX on November 25.
Photo: Brad Pitt — LucaFazPhoto, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Facts as reported by Variety, The Wrap and Collider, November 2026.