FAST. FRESH. FACTUAL.
Casting News

Lili Reinhart in Talks to Star in Polly Pocket Movie After Lily Collins Exit

Lili Reinhart in 2019
Lili Reinhart in 2019. Photo: Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Lili Reinhart is in talks to star as Polly Pocket in the long-awaited live-action Polly Pocket movie from Amazon MGM Studios and Mattel Studios, stepping into the lead role after Lily Collins exited the project over scheduling issues. Deadline first reported the casting news on Friday, November 20, with Variety also reporting the move.

The Casting Switch

Collins, 37, had been attached to star in and produce the film for five years, but she is no longer able to play the lead. She remains attached to the project as an executive producer. Reinhart, 30, best known for playing Betty Cooper on Riverdale, would also serve as an executive producer if the deal closes.

Reinhart is coming off the Prime Video romantic comedy The Love Hypothesis, which performed well on the streamer — a track record that fits a film Amazon MGM is developing for Prime Video. Casting a proven streaming draw signals the studio's confidence in the project, which has been in development for more than five years.

Who Is Making the Film

Clea DuVall is directing the film, from a screenplay by Jordan Weiss and Dan Brier. DuVall boarded the project over the summer, replacing Lena Dunham, who was originally set to write and direct before exiting in 2024. Weiss and Brier previously wrote the Kiernan Shipka and Nico Hiraga film Sweethearts; Weiss also co-wrote Freakier Friday and created the Hulu series Dollface.

The film is produced by Robbie Brenner for Mattel Studios and Reese Witherspoon and Lauren Neustadter for Hello Sunshine, which joined the project in 2025. Collins, Emily Ferenbach of Hello Sunshine, Jeff Waxman and Jennifer Madeloff are among the executive producers, alongside Mattel Studios.

What We Know So Far

· Release: the film is being developed for Prime Video; no release date has been announced
· Filming: reports have suggested production could begin in February 2027 in Toronto, though Amazon MGM has not confirmed a start date
· Story: no plot details have been announced
· Official comment: Amazon has not made any official comment confirming Reinhart's involvement

Polly Pocket began as a Mattel toy line in 1989 and has since spawned television shows, games and toys. The film is part of Mattel's push to bring its toy brands to the screen following the huge success of Barbie in 2023, with other Mattel projects in development including Barney, Hot Wheels and Rock 'Em Sock 'Em Robots.

Why This Casting Matters

The switch keeps one of Mattel's most recognisable brands moving after years in development. Collins' five-year attachment made her exit a setback, but a quick replacement — with Reinhart also taking an executive producer role — suggests Amazon MGM and Mattel want the film in front of cameras soon. If the deal closes, Reinhart will carry a franchise built on a toy that has been in children's hands for nearly four decades, and a studio hoping lightning strikes twice after Barbie.

Photo: Lili Reinhart — Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Facts as reported by Deadline and Variety, November 2026.